What The Schools Can Teach Us About Nurturing Values
Pat Harned and Kathyrn Sutliff
Passage of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 has ushered in a new era in the field of ethics and compliance. Already the organizational field has seen the growth of new lines of business for consulting groups--focusing on the means by which organizations can comply with the law and prevent future tragedy. Sarbanes-Oxley has become a priority for all organizations and ethics professionals.
Because the legislation requires CEOs to attest to their companies' financial statements (among many other mandates), it is in essence asking high-level personnel to certify the behavior of others. The cumulative effect of Sarbanes-Oxley and the certifications it requires is that organizations must now teach employees about ethics and encourage ethical behavior--and they must be more effective than ever before. In the field of ethics, the question is no longer "Why?" or "Whose?" or "Which?" or even "What?" The question is "How?"
How can our organizations ensure ethical behavior? How can we effectively communicate the values of our organization and the behaviors those values necessitate? How can we encourage employees to make good decisions? How can we guide our staff so that their actions and decisions are ones that we can stand behind--even certify?
Luckily, these questions do not call for the reinvention of the proverbial wheel. Discussions of right and wrong, unethical and ethical have been around for millennia. And, fortunately for us, throughout the ages people have struggled to answer the questions that are now before us.
In fact, individuals have been certifying the conduct of others for years. An entire body of knowledge has already been developed, focusing on the ways people learn to recognize and resolve ethical situations. This literature exists in the field of education, and while its language may be very different from the business world, the findings are relevant nonetheless. By looking at the successes and, especially, the failures of the educational world's efforts to impart values and nurture ethical behavior, business has the opportunity to discover which strategies work and which do not. When it comes to the teaching and learning of ethics, there is something CEOs can learn from elementary and secondary school teachers.
Therefore, let us make this bold claim: It is time for business to go back to school. There are lessons to be learned and business need not learn them the hard way.
Lessons from teachers
Over the past several years, schools have tried a number of different tactics to nurture values in their students. Through trial and error, they have discovered a number of strategies that make a difference.
The most successful strategies center around a specific set of core values--character traits that their community aspires to and chooses to focus upon. These values are made apparent in all facets of the life of the school community--posted in classrooms, illustrated in the handbook, used as points of reference for classroom management. Teachers discuss moral heroes, exemplars of these traits, who can be found in literature, history, the arts and sciences--real people, real examples from the curriculum. In an intentional way, core values become woven into the fabric of the school--infused in and nurtured by the culture of the community. Every teachable moment is seized so values can be discussed through the curriculum and reflected upon and practiced in everyday life. Student codes of conduct and disciplinary procedures refer to the core values to offer an explanation of the logic behind the rules. Behaviors consistent with the values are modeled and reinforced. Students are given time to reflect on the values and are offered numerous opportunities to put them into practice.
As a result of conscious decision, the school's core values become absolutely essential to the culture of the school community. The school knows its values. The school teaches its values. The school lives its values. And, over time, the school comes to embody its values.
At least that's how it should work--not that it always does.
The 7 deadly sins
Schools are not all that different from businesses in that their personnel are under great pressure to perform, with ever-increasing standards by which they are measured. With that pressure comes a temptation to cut corners, to take the easy way out--even to cheat--to get ahead. Like business leaders, teachers and school administrators pursue a goal of establishing an organizational culture that is based on a set of ethical standards so their personnel know how to handle the pressure. They aspire to ensure that the individuals within their context not only know what the right thing to do is, but that they will work hard to do it.
Archibald McLeish once said, "There is only one thing more painful than learning from experience and that is not learning from experience." So, we offer the following. Read about our experiences. Learn from our mistakes. Take the gems of wisdom that we have gained. And always, always avoid the seven deadly sins of any ethics initiative.
1. See no evil, hear no evil
Whereas in schools teachers get diverted from teaching ethics because of standardized tests and budget constraints, businesses get sidetracked from making ethics a priority due to performance objectives and budget constraints.
It probably goes without saying, but ethics will always be an issue. The temptation in both schools and businesses is often to ignore ethics altogether and focus on the more "pressing issues." In the educational world, where teachers are personally held accountable for their students' performance, educators are realizing that ethics is not only important, it is fundamental. Students who understand what it means to work hard, to have values, and to live by them perform better than those who do not. Classrooms based on values are more easily managed and are more productive than those that are not. Ethics can sometimes seem like a step to the side from what students need to learn, but it ends up being the foundation for all other activity.
Misconduct occurs in the business context where the pressure to perform outweighs the need to conduct good business. If employees know what it means to work hard, to have values and to act in a way that is consistent with organizational standards, they will perform better than those who merely respond to the pressure to perform.
Lesson from the schools #1: Recognize that character development has to be a priority and make the commitment to do something about it.
2. Passing the buck
Many teachers declare that there is already too much on their plates and that it's the responsibility of families to teach ethics. Similarly, business leaders may believe that it's not their responsibility or their right to teach ethics to their employees. They are in the business of business and not the business of character development.
Whether you choose to talk about ethics or not to talk about ethics, you are sending a message about ethics. Even in schools where there is a program in place, if teachers don't address ethics, students fail to see its relevance and significance. Ethics must be integrated into real life, everyday experiences if it is going to be meaningful and authentic.
Learning ethics is a life-long process. It doesn't stop when you graduate from college. Like it or not, if you want your employees to abide by your Code of Conduct, you have to teach them how. If you have expectations, you must help them live up to those expectations. You, therefore, are as much of a teacher as the person at the front of the classroom holding the chalk and the gradebook.
Lesson from the schools #2: Realize that you are always sending messages about what you value. Take responsibility and make the most of the opportunity presented to you.
3. Be a fence-sitter
Where schools might purchase a pre-packaged ethics curriculum complete with values and lessons ready to teach, businesses can adopt the best practices of another organization, or 'go through the motions' of setting up a compliance program that conforms minimally to the federal Sentencing Guidelines.
As ethics grew as an important priority for schools, so too did the industry for comparing notes and providing curricular help for teachers. Conferences, seminars, and consulting organizations surfaced to assist schools with the process of implementing values into the daily activities of the school. Too many schools either purchased programs that revolved around a set of pre-determined values, or they designed programs based upon the successful efforts of others. But because the program development was inorganic, teachers found it difficult to make natural connections between daily activities and the elements of the program. Time has revealed that programs that are "off the shelf" survive only a few years. Unless values reflect the needs, interests and priorities of the school itself, they are considered by students and teachers to be "fake."
Therefore, schools have increasingly invested time in processes that identify the values they really believe in, and developed 'grassroots' programs--grown from within their organizations. These are the ethics initiatives that have the greatest impact.
While "best practices" have emerged as a useful means by which business organizations can gauge leading efforts in the ethics industry, the pressures added to ethics programs by the Sarbanes-Oxley Act will require not only that a program be in place, but that work. Financial statements are only as truthful as the people who produce them. For this reason, ethics initiatives that are based upon anything other than the culture where they're taking place will not have a strong impact.
Lesson from the schools #3: For an ethics initiative to be successful, it has to be authentic. Take the time to create a program that meets the unique needs of your organization.
4. One hit wonder
In many schools, teachers address a concept and never feel the need to revisit and reinforce it. Similarly, many businesses train employees in ethics and compliance and, after having them sign documentation of the training, never address the issue again.
Simply put, once isn't enough. Just as students learn their multiplication tables by repetition, values have to be constantly reinforced--every day. Many schools talk about values once a month or once a week and fail to integrate them into the culture as a whole. This approach is a mistake: not only are educators failing to take advantage of the grand opportunity to teach ethics by modeling, they are inadvertently telling students that ethics only matters for a few minutes a day, or that particular values are only important for one month a year.
No doubt, ethics training for employees is a good thing. More specifically, it's a good start. Companies that fail to integrate ethics into daily interactions, informal and formal social systems, their culture, miss the point. Ethics is not just about informing employees about the right thing to do. It is not just about guiding them towards making good decisions. It is about creating a culture where core values are known, cherished, and lived.
Students don't learn their multiplication tables overnight. They don't learn about respect during the month of October alone. Similarly, employees don't become ethical simply by sitting through three hours of training on a Wednesday morning once a year.
Lesson from the schools #4: We learn by repetition. Talk about your values. Model your values. Reflect on your values. Again and again.
5. Keep your head in the clouds
For years, educators tried to encourage ethical behavior by elevating students' levels of moral reasoning. They offered students the opportunity to discuss arcane cases that had no relation to their experiences and ended up having little impact on their desire to be and do good. Some ethics offices have favored a similar approach: They rely solely upon generic case studies.
Although case studies have some merit as teaching tools, they just don't go far enough. Even if one can "solve" the great riddle of a particular case, there is not necessarily a correlative action. Knowing what you should do is not the same as doing it. It isn't even the same as wanting to do it. Furthermore, esoteric cases make rationalization very easy. Students and employees can quickly say to themselves, "Well, I know what I'm supposed to do in that situation, but what's going on here at my work is not exactly the same. Therefore, I don't have to do what that case study suggested."
The simple problem with case studies is that the principles are not always generalized. The emphasis is on the situation, not the values involved. The context, not the under-girding ethics, is the issue. It becomes a matter of getting the "right" answer instead of understanding why it is right.
The use of story is vitally important for teaching ethics. But we must be careful about the stories we choose to tell. Instead of just throwing out "what if" situations, we must offer "here's how" examples. By sharing the stories of moral heroes, we are offering guidance in the most constructive way possible. Heroes are people who had to struggle with ethical dilemmas. They provide examples of the innate worth of values. They demonstrate that one can, in fact, live an ethical life. By touching the aspirational part within each of us, moral heroes challenge us to examine our lives, encourage us to be better, offer us hope, and demonstrate the innate good of a life lived well.
Lesson from the schools #5: Use a variety of teaching tools. Real life is complicated and no one strategy can do it all.
6. Don't look where you're walking
Many schools choose to deal with behavior by making rules--lots of rules. In a similar fashion, many businesses focus on compliance with the law. In both cases, the results are, at best, pragmatic and incomplete, and, at worst, punitive and ineffective.
Every effective teacher knows that more classroom rules do not mean more effective discipline. Students are just too creative. They will always come up with something you couldn't have bargained for. Besides, the do's and don'ts fail to tell the whole story. "Because I said so" is a valid response to some of life's issues, but should not be the foundation for one's classroom management style. Students can successfully avoid breaking the rules while not adopting ethical behavior. Even if they are not doing something wrong, they are not necessarily doing something right.
Businesses fall into the same trap. No matter how many laws and rules a business must follow, there will always be gray areas. Sometimes codes don't provide enough of a guideline. Problems come up that were not anticipated. People have to have something to look up. By focusing on core values, businesses offer the ultimate guideline: When in doubt, this is what we care about. Core values redefine the problem and refocus the possible solutions.
It's often said that if you don't know where you're going, you're probably going to end up somewhere else. Core values let your employees know where you want them to go--and that's the only way they will ever get there.
Lesson from the schools #6: Focus on the values you want to instill. Teaching ethics is not about obeying a set of rules, it's about valuing values.
7. Do as I say not as I do
One of the most common downfalls in the teaching of ethics comes from the "hidden curriculum." The classic example is the teacher who gives students detentions for swearing and then uses foul language himself. The same thing happens in businesses that have a code, select core values, hold training sessions and are led by individuals who lack the values the company claims to espouse.
There is a famous poem called "Children Learn What They Live."(1) It is full of examples of how the behaviors of parents and teachers impact the children around them. Children pick up on actions and attitudes much more quickly and with a greater impact than any words could impose.
And this isn't only the case with kids. Employees look to their leaders for guidance. If CEOs and presidents focus on the bottom line, above all else, their employees will as well. If CEOs talk about ethics, but treat their employees in disrespectful ways, all of their ethics talk is worse than moot--it is hypocrisy.
But it's not just top management that matters. Research demonstrates that immediate supervisors and peers have a powerful influence on workplace ethics. Leaders can have the best of intentions, but unless their values are voiced regularly, they are seen as ethically neutral by their employees, at best.(2) If we really want to nurture ethical behavior and develop positive character traits, we must all be committed to being ethical role models for one another.
People learn what you tell them by your words and your choices. Living out values makes talking about them valid. Real leaders teach by example and know that their employees will be as committed to ethics as they are.
Lesson from the schools #7: Your actions speak louder than your words, so walk the talk.
We would like to present one addendum to our deadly sins: the problem of seeing only the bad. In schools, it means obsessing about catching wrongdoing instead of pointing out the good and ethical at every teachable moment. In businesses, it means worrying so much about violations and reporting misconduct that the ethics program fails to encourage and reward ethical behavior.
Lest any of us forget, there are schools that are doing it right and that are constantly trying to do it better. And there businesses that do successfully develop their employees' character.
So, we issue this challenge to you: do better than we have. Learn from the lessons of schools. Learn from the mistakes of this article. Focus on the good that is there and make it better. Which brings us to our last, but, not least lesson:
Above all else, look to the best, the highest ideal. Focus on the good and work towards attaining it.
1. D. L. Nolte, Ph. D. & R. Harris (1998). Natarajan, R., & Chaturvedi, R. (1983). Children learn what they live: Parenting to inspire values. New York: Workman Publishing.
2. Trevino, L., Hartman, L. & Brown, M. (2000). Moral person and moral manager: How executives develop a reputation for ethical leadership." California Management Review, 42(4).
The editors of Ethikos magazine have graciously granted permission to reprint this article which was originally published in the January 2003 issue of Ethikos. For more information about Ethikos, visit: http://www.singerpubs.com/ethikos/default.htm
ERC now offers federal agencies GSA contracts, contact us for more information.
Get Email Updates
Subscribe to receive periodic updates from ERC. Join our email list.
ERC President Pat Harned launches new blog; she welcomes discussion on ethics issues facing American workers and executives. Check out the blog!
Connect with ERC
ERC's Benchmarking Services
ERC's team can help you design and administer an ethics survey to fit your organization.